German court rules against YouTube in copyright test case

From Yahoo! News:
A German court ruled on Friday that Google's video sharing service YouTube is responsible when users post copyrighted music clips without permission.

In a test case that could have huge implications for YouTube if it has to pay royalties for all clips posted on its website, the German royalty collections body GEMA sued YouTube over 12 specific music videos to which it holds the rights.

The court ruled that YouTube is responsible for making sure that any uploaded videos do not breach copyright and ordered it to take down seven of the 12 clips concerned.

YouTube must install filters to prevent users from uploading copyrighted music videos without permission, it said.

If one of the seven videos concerned are re-posted on the website, YouTube could face a fine of up to 250,000 euros ($330,000), according to German law.

YouTube said it took no responsibility for what users did but responded when told of copyright violations.

GEMA, which represents about 60,000 German songwriters and musicians, expressed satisfaction with the ruling.

"YouTube must take measures to prevent violations in future," said GEMA's lawyer Kerstin Baecker.

"The court has clearly rejected the argument that YouTube as a host is not responsible for users' content."

The spat erupted after a licensing agreement between YouTube and GEMA expired in 2009. Negotiations on a replacement agreement have so far foundered owing to differences between the two sides.

A spokesman for Google Germany, Kay Oberbeck, said: "I now hope GEMA will return to the negotiating table."

Oberbeck described the ruling as "an important partial victory. The court has created legal certainty for platforms of user-generated content."

I'd like to hear what musician and songwriters think about having their songs uploaded on YT by other people. If I were a musician, I'd see that as a good publicity for my works. I don't think people don't buy CDs because they listen to the songs on YT. If someone really do like that, he's an ass***e.